Plastic from algae: How green?
A story in Discovery News on new algae-based plastic highlights green benefits but misses the challenges.
An article in Discovery News offers a rare look at how algae can be used to make something other than fuel or animal feed: plastic.
The story would have been more informative if the reporter had discussed the challenges that remain before algae fuels or plastics can become widespread. It is still not clear how algae can be produced sustainably on a large scale.
Reporter Alyssa Danigelis describes a new plastic that can be made with up to 50 percent algae. The company developing it hopes it will be 100 percent algae in a few years. Danigelis draws attention to the major green benefits of this new technology: it uses what would probably be a waste material from biodiesel production, it should not have any impact on the food supply, and further research and development could lead to a compostable material.
The 50 percent algae product also contains polypropylene (PP), a plastic often encountered in everyday life, for example, in microwaveable food containers. Such blends of natural and synthetic materials are not completely biodegradable but they often help to reduce consumption of limited resources.
By using algae left over from fuel extraction, this new plastic supports the idea of a “biorefinery.” The oil, coal and gas industries don’t just produce fuels – they produce the chemical building blocks for everything from industrial solvents to pharmaceuticals, leaving almost nothing to waste. Similarly, biofuel production will be more competitive if all of the raw materials are used productively. Plastic from algae is a step in that direction.
However, water, nutrient and energy demands can be extremely high and these issues are just as serious as whether the technology will compete with food production. Until the science is worked out, the “greenness” of algae – beyond its actual color – is not yet certain. The story could have made this more clear.